Jennifer Jason Leigh
Maria

Hope Davis
Madeleine Gravis

Tom Noonan
Sammy Barnathan

Sadie Goldstein
Olive (4 years old)

Robin Weigert
Adult Olive

Deirdre O'Connell
Ellen's Mother

Alice Drummond
Actress Playing Frances

Amy Wright
Burning House Realtor

Elizabeth Marvel
Warehouse Realtor

Christopher Evan Welch
Pastor