Nick's plan to let fate bring his wife to him must be altered because he must replace his father as Santa Claus on December 26. Ernst, the right-hand man to several generations of Santas, generates a list of potential mates. Nick dutifully sets off to meet them, but fate may have a candidate after all.
Wendy Braun
Amy
Kelley Hazen
Joanie
Mackenzie Fitzgerald
Jocelyn

Cody Arens
Christian

Robin Shorr
Meredith
John Wheeler
Santa
Taffy Wallace
Coach
Samantha Bennett
Marilyn
Ashlynn Bernard
Young Beth
Katia Coe
Holly